Georgetown University’s Newspaper of Record since 1920

The Hoya

Georgetown University’s Newspaper of Record since 1920

The Hoya

Georgetown University’s Newspaper of Record since 1920

The Hoya

VIEWPOINT: Exonerate Faarooq Mu’min Mansour


Georgetown University’s “Making an Exoneree” class has secured three exonerations during its four years of operation. I am fortunate enough to be a student in the course’s fifth year. My group, “Team Faarooq” — made up of Ty Greenberg (SFS ’22), Symone Harmon (COL ’22) and myself — believes our case will be the fourth. We are working to exonerate Andrew D. Lee (now Faarooq Mu’min Mansour) who has been imprisoned for 20 years for a crime he did not commit. 

Having reviewed the case in its entirety and gotten to know Faarooq on a personal level, we support his innocence — and know that significant exculpatory evidence exists. 

On March 25, 2002, Shauna Sandercock, the owner of a video game store, was murdered in the back room of her establishment. Her gun, stolen during the commission of the crime, was found in the possession of a known criminal in Atlanta months after the murder. 

A friend of Faarooq’s has signed an affidavit stating that the two of them were together outside of his house while the true perpetrator committed the crime. Most importantly, DNA profiles of two different men were found on the victim but were never run through the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), a national database that consists of the DNA profiles of convicted offenders. CODIS also includes profiles developed from evidence in unsolved crimes and evidence used to identify missing persons. 

Faarooq was scientifically excluded as matching neither of these profiles. The answers that CODIS could provide are essential to his exoneration.

On March 29, 2002, three dozen police officers and SWAT agents surrounded Faarooq Mu’min Mansour outside of his family home in Columbus, Ohio. Without knowing the crime for which he was being arrested, Faarooq believed this was a case of mistaken identity. Following the advice of his father, he allowed the police to handcuff him and take him for questioning. Unbeknownst to Faarooq and his parents, he would never return home.

Faarooq was wrongfully convicted in 2003 of robbery, kidnapping, rape and murder. He was, consequently, sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. 

At the root of his wrongful conviction is the insidious, pervasive and fatal grip that racism holds over the United States and its justice system. The Innocence Project found that “innocent Black people are seven times more likely to be wrongfully convicted of murder than innocent white people.” The statistic is even higher when the victim is white. 

Furthermore, exonerating innocent Black people takes approximately 45% longer than exonerating innocent white people. Faarooq’s life is forever changed by the racism and injustice epidemic plaguing the U.S. justice system.

His case is representative of how white supremacist ideology relies on the stereotyping of Black men as predators to justify mass incarceration, and Faarooq, a wrongfully convicted Black man, understands the role that racism played in his trial and conviction. 

Addressing the jury in his closing speech during sentencing, Faarooq noted that innocent Black men are too often accused of raping and murdering white women. For the past 20 years, he has been one of countless innocent Black men wrongfully convicted and wrongfully incarcerated. His jury, supposedly composed of 12 of his “peers,” included only one Black member, Faarooq said. 

Ever since his conviction, Faarooq has maintained his innocence and pleaded for more DNA testing to be done, knowing that it will prove without a doubt that he is telling the truth. His case, however, is at a standstill due to the denial of his motion to request a new trial.

Additionally, the three eyewitnesses who saw the suspect inside of the video store on March 25 were all white and their descriptions of the suspect’s physical appearance did not match Faarooq. Two of them picked Faarooq out of a photo lineup. The photo of Faarooq used in the lineup, however, was around a year old and did not match his appearance at the time of the crime. 

What’s more, the defense never called an expert witness to address potential issues with the administration of the photo lineup, or concerns about cross-racial identification, stress factors and weapon focus.

Now is the time to show Faarooq that you, the Georgetown community, believe in his innocence. Join us in our fight to exonerate him by spreading the word and garnering awareness. Faarooq, silenced and forgotten by our justice system, has been wrongfully incarcerated for 20 years — 20 years too long. 

Anna Marguleas is a junior in the College. 

View Comments (5)
More to Discover

Comments (5)

All The Hoya Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • S

    Scott McNeilMay 13, 2022 at 9:55 pm

    Lee was a repeat violent criminal and theif. His fingerprint was inside the store. He was on video outside the store with a gun. A friend of Lee’s saw Lee with a bracelet, after the murder, that was identical to the missing bracelet of the murder victim.
    This case was already heard by the Ohio Supreme Court. The court recited the facts found during the trial including: “Lee’s convictions arise out of the murder of Shauna Sandercock (hereinafter “the victim”) on March 25, 2002, in Columbus, Ohio. At approximately 1:50 p.m. on that day, the victim was found dead in a storeroom of a Game-Arama store located at 3103 West Broad Street that the victim owned with her fiancé. … The victim was found naked, on her knees, with her face down and her buttocks elevated. Dr. Keith Norton, an assistant county coroner, responded to the scene and found the body still warm at 2:30 p.m. After conducting an autopsy the following day, Dr. Norton opined the cause of death was blunt trauma to the victim’s neck by manual and ligature strangulation. [Prior to the discovery of the murder,] an African-American man came out of the storeroom, wiping his face with a bandana or rag and carrying a semi-automatic weapon. The gunman told the three customers to leave, and they did. As Richard Taylor, Jr. neared the door, he observed the gunman pick up something off the floor. The Taylors left the store, went to Rally’s nearby, and asked someone to call 9-1-1. West ran out of the store to his mother’s house that was near. As he arrived at the home, he turned and saw the fleeing African-American man, who was now carrying a backpack. By photo array and at trial, West and Richard Taylor, Jr. positively identified the gunman as defendant (Lee); they were “one hundred percent” confident of their identification.”
    “Forty minutes after the murder, Lee arrived at the Minnefield house. “Teresa Minnefield looked for a lighter in defendant’s jacket pocket and pulled out a bracelet. Defendant became agitated and told her not to go through his pockets. Ebony Finch and Dorothy Minnefield argued over the bracelet. Ebony Finch took the bracelet and later turned it in to the police. The victim’s fiancé testified that the bracelet Teresa found and Ebony took was exactly like the bracelet that the victim always wore, but did not have when her body was discovered.“
    The Ohio Supreme Court held “ we reverse defendant’s convictions of rape and aggravated murder premised on rape and modify the judgment to reflect verdicts of guilt on one count of attempted rape and one count of aggravated murder predicated on attempted rape, the other verdicts remaining unaltered, and we remand for resentencing of defendant consistent with this court’s opinion.”
    Your allegation that Lee was convicted because of racism is itself racist.

  • S

    SoniaApr 20, 2022 at 7:31 am

    Amazing work Anna, you are a star!

  • H

    Harold LeeApr 10, 2022 at 11:46 am

    Hi Anna,
    You, Ty, and Symone are doing an excellent job with this case. Honors to you three students who have been working hard to free Faarooq. Extended honors go to those who choose to participate in this effort to help the unfortunate people who are serving time for crimes that they did not commit.
    Harold Lee

  • J

    John BoninaApr 9, 2022 at 3:03 pm

    Great work Ms. Marguleas! Best of luck in obtaining this exoneration!
    JB, CAS 1987

  • A

    Anna MarguleasApr 8, 2022 at 10:19 pm

    Here is a link to all of our social media sites for Faarooq:

    Please consider signing our petition and following along on Instagram.